The very early history of Center Hill begins back in 1842.  Elethorn Mobley was issued 160.24 acres, dated the 4th day of March, 1842.  The families of Elethorn,  John Mobley, and John Walter were some of the pioneers of Center Hill and Sumter County.  They first called this area "Abram Town" or "Mobley Town".  The Indians called Center Hill "Pochechey".  This area extended from north of the present Highway 50 to near Beville's Corner.  In 1881, Captain Major Lovell moved into this area from what is now Lake County.  Mrs. Carrie Lovell named this little town "Center Hill" as it was in the center of the county and on top of a hill.

Dr. Spicer joined with Major Lovell in buying much of this land in 1881; he was the first to put in a drug store, and the second grocery store; he was also the first postmaster.  Dr. J. J. Outlaw, from Nortonville, Kentucky, practiced dentistry in Center Hill for many of the early years.  Cash was very rare; pay came in the form of barter.  He would travel from house to house to see his patients.

The old pool near the Antiock church was a favorite place for swimming, picnics and Baptisms.  Public schools have been operating in Center Hill before the high school was built in 1922.  However, the building was soon outgrown and another high school was built and it is still standing down by the railroad tracks east of town.  This building served the Center Hill community until around 1928-29.  When the students were enrolled in the Bushnell High School and were transported by bus to Bushnell. The population of the town decreased and it was no longer advisable to maintain a high school in Center Hill.

The freeze of 1894-95 slowed activity in the town.  The early part of 1900 Center Hill became a "boom" town.  It became the leading string bean capital of the world, shipping nearly 400 railroad cars of string beans that year.

Center Hill was the only town in Sumter County that could boast both Western Union and Postal Telegraph offices in the early days.